k_Street Consulting, LLC Blog

Updating the Whole Net Neutrality Situation

Updating the Whole Net Neutrality Situation

Net Neutrality in the United States has been a hot-button issue for almost anyone that uses the Internet. 2018 saw the 2005 principles governing the preservation of an open Internet repealed completely, leaving control over the Internet in the hands of huge companies that deliver Internet services to people. Today, we’ll go back over Net Neutrality and provide an update of what has happened since the Federal Communications Commission repeal of net neutrality laws.

Commercially available Internet services have been available since the early 1990s, but as broadband was being implemented, the Internet, and investment in the medium was strong. In an attempt to keep control of the Internet distributed among the people that utilize the service, and not massive corporations looking to gain control over it, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) under chair Kathleen Abernathy adopted neutrality principles “to preserve and promote the vibrant and open character of the Internet as the telecommunications marketplace enters the broadband age” in 2005.

For seven years, lawmakers attempted to pass bills in Congress that would secure an open future for the Internet. All of these attempts failed, leaving the future of who would control the Internet up in the air. The fear was that ISPs, which are typically huge multinational conglomerates, would be able to control bandwidth with cost, as they do with their television services. Internet freedom advocates considered the price discrimination that would arise from “local monopolies enshrined in law” to be at the helm of what has proven to be the most remarkable invention in human history, counterproductive for the establishment of an open and useful construct.

Years of litigation followed. Cases such as Verizon Communications Inc. vs. FCC, which ruled that the FCC had no regulatory power over the Internet because it was, in fact, not actually a utility, and thus, governed under Title I of the Communications Act of 1934. Immediately after this ruling, the FCC took steps to reclassify Internet delivery services into a public utility, which are governed under Title II of the Act. In February of 2015, the classifications were officially challenged as voting members agreed that Internet services met the criteria of a utility under Title II of the Communications Act of 1934 and the more recent Telecommunications Act of 1996. In April of 2015 “net neutrality” was upheld by officially declaring Internet services as a utility. The rules officially went into effect the following June.

The “final rule” turned out to be short lived, however. In April of 2017, the FCC proposed to repeal the policies that governed net neutrality, and return control to the corporations that invest in and provide broadband services. The proposed changes were met with heavy consternation, with over 20 million people providing comments during the public discourse phase of the process. It was later found that millions of the comments made in support of net neutrality repeal were made fraudulently by foreign actors. Despite the overwhelming dissention of the mass of people, the FCC repealed the net neutrality policies and followed it with a hefty amount of propaganda material claiming that the decision was “restoring Internet freedom”. The repeal became official in June of 2018.

What Is Going on with Net Neutrality Now?
Almost immediately after the change was made there have been several lawsuits filed and they seem to keep coming. States, advocacy groups, neutrality lobbies, and companies have all started lawsuits against the FCC both for their handling of the situation and for the repeal of net neutrality itself.

One way to ascertain if it has been a benefit is by looking at the claims the FCC made before dismantling the mandate:

  1. Net Neutrality is hindering broadband investment. In 2018 what is known as the Big Four--Verizon, AT&T, Charter, and Comcast--collectively spent less in broadband projects than they did in 2017. It was the first time in three years that investment has dropped.
  2. It doesn’t make sense for ISPs to throttle Internet traffic. The Big Four reportedly slowed internet traffic without telling customers not more than six weeks after the repeal. Sites like YouTube, Netflix, and Amazon Prime were the most targeted. Verizon was especially culpable as it was found to slow data speeds that led to slower EMS response times; a major problem as firefighters were battling massive fires in California.

The issue isn’t totally devoid of common ground, however. Almost everyone believes that ISPs shouldn’t be able to flex their muscles, so to speak. One way this is happening is that there is a push to restore older FCC mandates that prohibited ISPs to enact anticompetitive and harmful practices. Basically, everyone wants a fast, open, and unobstructed Internet, but the disagreement, usually on party lines, is who is responsible for the regulation.

An extreme majority of people support net neutrality. Most people want to return oversight over the Internet to the bureaucracy, as they believe that corporations whose stated purpose is to make profit aren’t the best organizations to manage something as important as access to the Internet, despite being the companies that sell that access. Time will tell who is right.

If you would like to do something about it, go to https://www.battleforthenet.com/ and sign up. Do you believe market forces will keep ISPs honest, and the Internet open? Leave your thoughts in the comments section below.



No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Monday, March 25 2019

Captcha Image

Mobile? Grab this Article!

QR-Code dieser Seite

Tag Cloud

Cybersecurity End of Support Entertainment Search Amazon Web Services Machine Learning Password Manager Consultant Accountants Multi-Factor Security Online Shopping HaaS Social Engineering Point of Sale Hacking CES Staff BYOD Managed Service Office Tips Business Computing malware Software Tips Google Docs Business Windows Media Player Content Filtering Data Backup Phone System Network Congestion Video Games Operating System Retail Cryptomining HBO Robot eWaste Data loss Employee Enterprise Content Management Analytic avoiding downtime IT Services Printer Server Upgrade PowerPoint Data Protection Hring/Firing Wire Smart Office Camera Internet Exlporer Loyalty Business Owner Virtual Desktop webinar Smartwatch Apple NIST Root Cause Analysis Servers Utility Computing Education Transportation Specifications Workplace Tips Disaster Recovery Cast Fiber-Optic Google Drive USB Streaming Media Reputation Operating Systems SaaS Hard Drives SharePoint eCommerce Scam Database Hybrid Cloud Workforce Help Desk Strategy Evernote Google Apps Antivirus Social Media Statistics Outsourced IT Restore Data Gadgets Remote Worker Content Botnet Trending Relocation Recovery analytics Data Security Windows 7 IT Support Artificial Intelligence IT Solutions Saving Time Risk Management Telecommuting Best Practice Managed IT Services Managing Stress Nanotechnology OneNote Virtual Private Network Windows 10s Virtual Reality Tip of the Week Keyboard Files Current Events Unified Communications Password Management Automation communications Monitor Windows 10 Programming Server Application Computer Accessories Cleaning Bandwidth Read Sports Amazon Digital Signature Identity Theft HVAC Start Menu Automobile Outlook Credit Cards Criminal How To Bloatware Holiday Content Management Content Filter Humor IaaS Employee/Employer Relationship Document Management Government Work/Life Balance Mobile Device Management Human Resources Smartphone People Multiple Versions ISP Managed Service Provider Smartphones Authentication User Law Enforcement IT Plan Settings Firewall Emergency CrashOverride Battery Tablet Remote Monitoring Managed IT Services Pain Points Digital Payment Cloud Computing Augmented Reality Productivity Unified Threat Management IT Support E-Commerce Shadow IT Windows 10 Saving Money Books IT Management Productivity Software as a Service Insurance Gaming Console Millennials Browser Data WIndows 7 Data Warehousing Screen Mirroring Inventory Microchip Computer Repair Biometrics Connectivity Sync Tools IT solutions Update Public Cloud Voice over Internet Protocol Network Security Office Word Vendor Manufacturing Worker Tech Term Students IBM Smart Tech VPN Employer Employee Relationship Marketing Maintenance Cache Audiobook Memory Experience HIPAA Save Time Spam Cameras Cloud Ransomware Lifestyle Display Cables Thought Leadership Business Technology Emails Two-factor Authentication Safety Telephone Systems Privacy Regulation Backup Wireless Internet Best Available Security Cameras Worker Commute Training Save Money Workers Entrepreneur Wireless Technology Customer Service Storage travel Printer Hosted Solutions Company Culture Music Mobile Devices Virtual Assistant IT Consultant Physical Security Running Cable Excel Practices Flexibility Smart Technology Software Data Breach Virtualization Administrator Hardware Wi-Fi Skype Uninterrupted Power Supply Administration Black Market Information Scalability Hiring/Firing Touchpad Managed IT Gmail Applications Alert Instant Messaging Touchscreen Professional Services Advertising Access Control Legal Search Engine Cortana Data storage Assessment Going Green Hosted Computing Computer Fan Electronic Medical Records Wireless Charging Health Domains Tablets Fax Server Android User Error Collaboration MSP Samsung Webinar Mobile Device Techology Computers Digital Signage Cost Management Computing Infrastructure Internet exploMicrosoft Business Continuity Audit Budget Tip of the week Paperless Office Customer Relationship Management Microsoft Office Quick Tips Troubleshooting Logistics Tech Support Bring Your Own Device Google Apps Politics GDPR Mobility Money BDR Proactive IT PDF Technology Archive Bing App User Tips iphone Network Fraud Data Storage Line of Business Wearable Technology Regulations Innovation Warranty Customers Data Recovery Laptop Business Mangement Microsoft File Versioning Two Factor Authentication Best Practices Telephone System Website Product Reviews Electronic Health Records Wireless Social Data Management Environment Mobile Computing Remote Work Colocation Notifications Netflix Supercomputer Windows 8 Theft Computer Bluetooth Router Mobile DDoS History Online Currency The Internet of Things Hackers Flash Analysis Facebook Spam Blocking Biometric Security Addiction Security Redundancy Mobile Office Telephony Big data Blockchain Computer Care Business Management Frequently Asked Questions Net Neutrality Passwords Thank You Downtime Phishing Networking Congratulations File Sharing Office 365 Hacker Public Computer Vendor Management Television Small Business Chromecast Solid State Drive LinkedIn IT service Cryptocurrency Internet of Things Meetings Communication Users Mouse Value Twitter Benefits Recycling Shortcut WiFi Vulnerability Cybercrime Conferencing Analyitcs Hosted Solution YouTube FENG Remote Monitoring and Maintenance Business Intelligence Encryption How to Intranet Patch Management Email Windows Server 2008 Unsupported Software VoIP Information Technology NarrowBand Chrome Lithium-ion battery Miscellaneous Comparison Knowledge Project Management Employer-Employee Relationship Internet Remote Computing Science Virus Private Cloud Efficiency Safe Mode Shortcuts Wiring Windows Proactive Rootkit Printers Password Infrastructure Google Search Leadership Devices Healthcare Backup and Disaster Recovery Charger Distribution IoT Compliance Distributed Denial of Service Social Networking

Sign up for our Newsletter!

  • Company Name *
  • First Name *
  • Last Name *