k_Street Consulting, LLC Blog

Tip of the Week: Are Workplace Wellness Programs Effective? It Depends

Tip of the Week: Are Workplace Wellness Programs Effective? It Depends

Workplace wellness programs, despite being an $8 billion industry, are a bit of a quandary for employers - as the jury is still out over whether or not these kinds of programs are effective. For this week’s tip, we’ll examine if a wellness program might be a good fit for you.

Study after study has been performed over the years about the impact of workplace wellness programs, producing various results. Some have indicated health improvements and cost savings, while others haven’t. However, the studies that were performed in the past had a high rate of issues. Whether there was no comparison group, or the chance of personal bias influencing signups, these studies simply didn’t provide reliable data.

Now, however, researchers from the University of Chicago and Harvard have conducted a large-scale study that meets the requirements that such a study is usually beholden to.

The BJ’s Wholesale Club Experiment

This experiment began by selecting 20 of the big-box retailer’s outlet centers to offer an employee wellness program. 140 additional BJ’s locations did not offer any such program. Across the 160 clubs involved, there were almost 33,000 workers employed.

Participants filled out a health risk questionnaire, took health classes, and had basic medical tests performed. After 18 months, their progress was evaluated...and that’s where things got interesting.

Despite the workers who were participating in this program reporting healthier behaviors than they once exhibited, almost all other factors were left unchanged. Blood sugar levels, job performance and attendance, and employer health care spending all were unaffected.

Why This Might Be

There’s a good chance that the results of this study were skewed by the incentives offered to participants. Participants were given gift cards for attending wellness courses, for a total incentive of about $250. According to founder and CEO of Bravo Wellness, Jim Pshock, this may just not have been enough. According to Pshock, any amount less than $400 is only going to be enough to incentivize people to do what they were already going to do anyways. As Pshock put it: “It’s simply too small to get them to do things they weren’t already excited about.”

Another study, published in 2018 by the University of Illinois, essentially debunked the idea of the workplace wellness program, concluding that it neither reduced costs or impacted behaviors - although this study also found that participants of wellness programs were those who were already healthy and motivated. This potentially suggests that the true benefit of these programs isn’t to make their existing workforce healthier, but to attract and retain healthier employees.

There are other potential contributing factors as well. A recent survey indicated that 84 percent of employees saw their wellness programs as “one-size-fits-all,” a concept that doesn’t really work will all of the various factors that contribute to health. Eighty percent of respondents to that same survey claimed that more personalization would contribute to their participation in wellness programs.

Why You Want to Adopt a Workplace Wellness Initiative

Admittedly, we’ve provided a mixed defense for these kinds of activities, but it cannot be denied that anything you can do to promote the health of your employees will only benefit your business - healthy employees tend not to call in sick, after all.

There are other benefits to these programs as well:

  • Reduced Stress - The stress management benefits of healthier behaviors have been well documented. By adopting these healthier behaviors, you and your staff can reduce the stress that comes from the office and approach the source issues more effectively.

  • Community Building - As the boss, you want your entire team to work as, well, a team. Unfortunately, if certain departments don’t work together much, this kind of relationship can be hard to develop. However, many activities that would fall under a workplace wellness initiative can help cross departmental lines, drawing your team closer together.

  • Better Moods - Wellness programs allow employees to try out new activities, which can not only add to their wellbeing, but can also keep them engaged and productive. Plus, studies have indicated that employees who participate in these programs were generally happier with their work situation.

What have you done to cultivate a more health-conscious workplace? Share your strategies in the comments!

Are You Leveraging these Invaluable Business Tools...
Even Small Businesses are Targets for Hackers
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Friday, July 19 2019

Captcha Image

Mobile? Grab this Article!

QR-Code dieser Seite

Tag Cloud

Knowledge Leadership Content Filter WiFi CES Public Cloud Hiring/Firing Shortcuts Storage Trending SharePoint Battery User Tips Science Disaster Recovery Data Touchscreen Cache Staff Word Administration Insurance Holiday Workers Worker Commute Best Practice Mobile Device Database Security Electronic Health Records Audit Mouse Twitter Television IBM Entrepreneur Analyitcs IT solutions Spam Blocking Telephony Value Bluetooth Remote Computing Digital Signature Cybersecurity Bring Your Own Device Display Access Control IaaS Hybrid Cloud Accountants Business Owner analytics Legal Regulation IT Management Social Media Remote Monitoring Apple Unsupported Software Paperless Office Smartphones Wireless Enterprise Content Management Microchip Cryptocurrency Amazon Web Services Hring/Firing Loyalty Cables Remote Maintenance Hosted Computing Inventory Fiber-Optic Proactive Maintenance Safe Mode Managed IT PowerPoint Printer Redundancy Computer Accessories Risk Management IT Support Managed IT Services Gadgets Sync Retail Information Technology IT Plan How to Keyboard Gmail Cast End of Support Social Networking Bing Work/Life Balance Manufacturing HBO Hosted Solutions ROI HVAC Document Management Cloud Computing GDPR Unified Threat Management Analytic Bloatware Compliance Healthcare Employer-Employee Relationship Downtime Hackers Virtual Private Network Netflix Benefits Programming Servers Microsoft Music Small Business WIndows 7 Save Money Training Efficiency Chromecast Innovation NarrowBand Hardware Email Environment Google communications Software Tips Save Time Books Administrator Google Apps Biometrics DDoS Machine Learning Memory Quick Tips Business Continuity Frequently Asked Questions Encryption Upgrade Office Proactive Biometric Security Two-factor Authentication Smart Tech Technology Tablet Uninterrupted Power Supply SaaS Cortana Networking Amazon Alert Robot Internet exploMicrosoft Windows 10 Transportation Mobile Office Entertainment LinkedIn Vulnerability Black Market Backup Data Management Miscellaneous ISP Current Events avoiding downtime IT Infrastructure Data storage Communication Productivity Virtualization Cloud Monitor Data Warehousing Webinar Theft Firewall Tip of the week Operating Systems Wire Health Troubleshooting Tech Support Vendor Management Point of Sale Relocation Gaming Console Thank You Smart Office Read Wireless Charging Company Culture Windows Media Player Internet Exlporer Windows 10 Cabling Virtual Reality Thought Leadership Unified Communications Solid State Drive FENG Streaming Media Windows Server 2008 Phishing Settings Antivirus Scam Private Cloud Saving Money Productivity Video Games Smart Technology Conferencing Apps Marketing Hacker Safety User Google Docs Running Cable Techology Vendor Domains Privacy IT Consultant Network Congestion USB Infrastructure Practices Two Factor Authentication Social Engineering Managed Service Provider Sports Humor IT Solutions Applications Information Computers Experience Congratulations Remote Work NIST Content Filtering webinar Flash Mobile Device Management Big data Fax Server Network Telecommuting Website IT service Best Available Microsoft Office Smartwatch Going Green Identity Theft Office Tips Digital Payment MSP PDF Remote Monitoring and Maintenance HaaS Windows Server 2008 R2 Excel Blockchain Business Intelligence Screen Mirroring Warranty Proactive IT Ransomware Tools Computing Infrastructure 5G Students Employee/Employer Relationship Customer Relationship Management Internet of Things YouTube Virtual Desktop Fraud Audiobook Addiction eWaste Notifications Automation Touchpad IT Support Tablets Evernote Comparison Start Menu Cost Management Default App Content Computer Repair Augmented Reality Assessment Root Cause Analysis Search Engine Cameras Business Management OLED Regulations Automobile Windows 8 Data Security Chrome Content Management Connectivity Printers Customer Service Skype Smartphone Worker Spam Shortcut Computer Workforce Devices The Internet of Things Update eCommerce Passwords Google Search Patch Management Law Enforcement OneNote E-Commerce Mobile Social How To Digital Signage Advertising Cryptomining Network Security Emails Telephone Systems Managed IT Services Router Product Reviews Nanotechnology Internet Wireless Internet Public Computer Rootkit Maintenance Windows 7 Cleaning Voice over Internet Protocol Processor Physical Security Net Neutrality iphone Tip of the Week File Versioning Wearable Technology Managed Service Remote Worker Artificial Intelligence VoIP Data loss Office 365 Password Manager Tech Term Consultant Politics Wi-Fi Operating System Human Resources Archive Data Recovery Managing Stress User Error Emergency Reputation Hard Drives Money Google Drive Password File Sharing Laptop Lithium-ion battery Charger Instant Messaging Electronic Medical Records Phone System Application CrashOverride Bandwidth Authentication Multiple Versions Employee Multi-Factor Security travel Outlook Printer Server Data Backup Lifestyle Restore Data History App Telephone System Help Desk Files Budget Specifications Criminal BYOD Customers Samsung Password Management Hosted Solution Mobile Devices Software as a Service VPN Logistics HIPAA Mobile Computing Botnet Intranet Business Mangement Analysis Business Online Currency Virtual Assistant Best Practices Users Data Breach Statistics Server Colocation Business Computing Professional Services Computer Care BDR Flexibility Facebook Data Protection Project Management Security Cameras Government Employer Employee Relationship Mobility Computer Fan Outsourced IT Software Browser Distribution Distributed Denial of Service Hacking People Recycling Scalability Windows Online Shopping Collaboration Recovery malware Credit Cards Pain Points Wireless Technology Search Strategy Investment IoT Education Workplace Tips Meetings Business Technology Data Storage Virus Cybercrime Wiring Camera Windows 10s Supercomputer Backup and Disaster Recovery Shadow IT Line of Business IT Services Android Managed Services Provider Utility Computing Millennials Saving Time

Sign up for our Newsletter!

  • Company Name *
  • First Name *
  • Last Name *